Personal Trainers for Preschool Kids?

I came across an article yesterday that just begged to be commented on. The piece was titled "Personal Trainers for Kids on the Increase: Kids Working with Fitness Experts Hone Skills, Lose Weight, Get Healthy."

Anyone familiar with my work knows I'm all in favor of fitness for kids. In fact, it's one of my crusades. But this story worried me. With the children's obesity crisis raging (and it truly is a crisis) and more and more parents looking to help their kids become physically skilled, there are plenty of people willing to take advantage. These people will promise to "accelerate" your child's skill development or get him or her "pumped up." The problems are: It isn't possible to accelerate skill development...and strength training isn't appropriate for children under 12. Here's why the latter should be avoided if you have a young child:

• Children's bodies aren't fully developed. Therefore, strength training, handled improperly, can do more harm than good, particularly in children under 6, who are most prone to injury.

• Young children have short attention spans, meaning they don't have the motivation to endure the monotony of repetitive exercises.

• Young children don't yet have the cognitive ability to follow instructions and understand the risks and benefits of using strength-training equipment. The experts recommend children be at least 10 -- preferably 12 -- before handling strength-training equipment.

As far as accelerated skill development is concerned, there's no scientific evidence that getting an early start leads to improved performance. There is, however, research showing that children who learn skills when they're developmentally ready learn them more easily.

So, if you're concerned about your child's fitness, good for you! But if you're worried that you need an expert, in the form of personal trainers or organized programs, rest assured that it's much simpler than that. For young children, the best strength training involves the use of their own body weight in activities they'd be doing anyway...like running and jumping, pumping higher and higher on a swing, climbing the monkey bars, or playing tug-of-war. Yes, this might seem old-fashioned. But if you're like me, these were the kinds of activities you were doing when you were a kid...and there was no childhood obesity crisis back then.

Rae Pica
www.movingandlearning.com

9/20/2007 7:00:00 AM
Rae Pica
Written by Rae Pica
Rae Pica is a children’s physical activity specialist and the author of 14 books, including her latest release: A Running Start: How Play, Physical Activity, and Free Time Create a Successful Child
View Full Profile

Comments
What a bold move on your cousin's part, Bryan! I know a young woman whose mother took the TV right out of the house every summer. Today she and her young children are among the most active of families I know, and she credits it directly to her mother's actions. I've accepted that we can't bring back the "old days" when kids roamed free outdoors, but we've got to make some changes -- fast! -- because overweight and obesity aren't the only problems arising from too much TV and too much sedentary living.
Posted by raepica
Kudos to you Rae. These days everyone is looking for the quick fix. "My kid is overweight, OK, I'll get him a personal trainer." That's the lazy way out b/c the parents don't want to educate themselves on what they can do to help their own children. How 'bout give them healthier, home-cooked meals? Throw out all the junk food. Stop setting a bad example for your kids. I could go on and on. I think parents are lazy today. About 10 years ago, my cousin, when in his mid-30s, was driving home from his job; he had gotten off early that day, it was about 3:30pm, on an Autumn weekday. As he drove through his neighborhood in Long Beach, LI, he noticed something strange. There were no kids outside playing. He thought this was weird. He thought back to when he was a kid; 3:30pm was prime playing time, what's going on here? As he drove down his own block he was looking for his son and daughter, they were about 10 and 8 in age. He didn't see them. He parked in his driveway and walked into his house to find his son and daughter in separate rooms; one was watching TV, the other was playing a video game. It hit him like a ton of bricks. That night he told his wife that he was throwing the TVs out the next day. His wife flipped out; "WHAT?! What about the stuff I like to watch?" He knew they had to set a drastic example. He followed through with his word and explained his reasoning to his kids. They weren't happy, but they dealt with it. They played outside more, played with each other, played with others, they read a lot more books, etc. They are both amazing college students now, traveling and studying abroad, and getting great grades. Our kids will not be obese if we don't let them eat junk and sit in front of TVs, video games, and computers all day! They don't need personal trainers, they need a childhood of fun!
Posted by Bryan

Related Keywords

Wellness.com does not provide medical advice, diagnosis or treatment nor do we verify or endorse any specific business or professional listed on the site. Wellness.com does not verify the accuracy or efficacy of user generated content, reviews, ratings or any published content on the site. Use of this website constitutes acceptance of the Terms of Use.
©2024 Wellness®.com is a registered trademark of Wellness.com, Inc. Powered by Earnware